A performer, Yaelokre, stands on stage holding a guitar. They have short blond hair, and are wearing glasses and a patterned shirt. They, along with the stage set of vintage furniture (some covered with a sheet), are lit predominantly with a blue light. Behind the stage is a pair of stone arches, with black clothes and strings of fairy lights filling both; the edge of the arches is painted red, white and green. Between the two arches is a stone head; on the arch around it, in gold text on blue, are painted the words "Chalmers, 1780-1847". In front of the stage are silhouetted concertgoers.

The charts of the charts

Last week I was ranting about the albums chart, with my main thesis being that it isn’t what it used to be. This week, I have the data to prove it.

As I mentioned last week, I had to collect this manually. I noted down the top 100 albums for the charts that were valid on 1st November 2001 and 1st November 2026. As well as the chart position, title, artist, and number of weeks on the chart (as of the chart date), I also found from other sources1 the release date, and whether or not it was a compilation or greatest hits album.2 Let’s have a look at what that tells us.

I’m going to start by looking at how long ago the albums came out, as of the relevant chart date. Since we’re talking about age, I thought it might be fun to show that via a population pyramid, because I have a strange idea of fun.

A bar chart in the style of a population pyramid: there is a central vertical axis, from which horizontal bars protrude to either side, representing ages. The left-hand side represented the chart on 1st November 2001, in which there is a very large bar for age zero, and almost nothing above age 10. On the right, representing 1st November 2026, there are more older albums, with a fairly high density up to age 25 and a few up to the 50s.
I told you it was fun.

Back in 2001, more than two-thirds of the albums on the chart (68, to be precise) had come out within the previous year, and almost all were in the preceding 10 years. There were only, in fact, four albums in the charts dating back to the 1980s or earlier: two by Michael Jackson (Thriller and Bad), one by U2 (The Joshua Tree), and the oldest, Goodbye Yellow Brick Road by Elton John, which was a venerable 28-year-old.

In the chart from 2026, the share of what, for want of a better word, we’ll call “newborn” albums had dropped from more than two-thirds to less than one-fifth. Actually, there were fewer albums with a single-digit age in 2026 (58) than there were newborn albums in 2001. The 10-year cutoff from 2001 is now more analogous to a 40-year cutoff: there were five albums older than that in the chart from this year. (You can probably guess who they’re by: have a guess, then have a look in the footnote to see how well you did.3) And the thing I find interesting about that is that the threshold has moved by more than time that has passed between the charts: it’s not just that the same old stuff is hanging around, but that the content is getting actively older.

As I probably should have guessed, the ”number of weeks on the chart” variable correlates heavily with the age one, so doesn’t really tell us much new.

A scatter plot, with age (in weeks) along the bottom and weeks on the chart up the side, both as logarithmic axes—so there are evenly spaced axis markers for 1, 10, 100 and 1,000. There is also a dashed line shown connecting the points where the values on both axes are the same. Almost all the points fall below the line, but there is a generally increasing pattern. The dots are coloured according to the chart date, meaning there is a cluster of dots for the 2026 near the top and more of the 2021 dots are near the bottom.
I think this graph is also the best evidence you should take this with a pinch of salt, because my data collection may have been shonky—there’s no other explanation for the albums that have been on the chart for longer than they’ve been out.

However, I did think it might be interesting to see, for the top five songs, how many weeks they’d spent on the chart as of 1st November 2001. That required a little more data collection for four of those albums, because they weren’t actually in the chart on that day. But I was happy to oblige.

ArtistAlbumWeeks as of 01/11/2026Weeks as of 01/11/2001DifferencePercentage
ABBAABBA Gold: Greatest Hits1,27743284565%
Bob Marley and the WailersLegend1,26043282863%
QueenGreatest Hits1,23054069053%
Fleetwood MacRumours1,17350067352%
Oasis(What’s the Story) Morning Glory?77318159245%

The 2026 chart is exactly 1,305 charts later than the 2001 one, so the percentage column shows the fraction of intervening charts that each album has appeared on. Which leads to the rather astonishing conclusion that ABBA Gold has appeared on almost two-thirds of the charts issued in the last 25 years. I mean, it’s a good album, but what’s going on?

Now is probably time to talk about the elephant in the room: the greatest hits albums. Here’s what I like to call a barcode graph: the horizontal axis progresses from the top of the chart on the left to the number 100 on the right, and each bar “lights up” in yellow if the album at that position is a compilation.

A chart in the form of a grid of tall, narrow rectangles, in two rows with 100 in each row. The rows represent the two charts, and the columns represent chart positions. There are a lot more yellow rectangles in the row for the 2026 chart, with more towards the higher-numbered chart positions.
I admit I was concerned my argument would fall apart when I looked at the 2001 chart, and the very first album was the then-recently released Gold: Greatest Hits by Steps.

I don’t think I need to comment much on this one.

So what’s going on? I don’t know exactly, but I have a guess: streaming.

The distinction between the singles and albums charts made sense when singles ran at 45 rpm and albums at 33⅓.4 Cassette and CD singles might have looked the same, but you could still distinguish them by length. Even in the download era, where the distinction between downloading a “single” and downloading a single track from an album became blurred, you could at least tell whether someone had purchased the whole thing or just a bit of it.

But what exactly do you count as one stream of an album? Have a think about it, because from trying to come up with a way myself I don’t envy the Official Charts Company. As an example: suppose someone streams a playlist of top ABBA tracks. At first that’s probably functionally equivalent to streaming ABBA Gold—but as they go down the list they’ll start to tick off some of the earlier albums from which the songs were taken. At that point, should you take the compilation album back off the list?

Fortunately, the Official Charts Company tells you how they do it. And I’ll tell you more about that next week.

To be continued…

  1. Let’s be honest: mostly Wikipedia. ↩︎
  2. This last one required some judgement. For example, technically, last year’s I’ve Tried Everything but Therapy by Teddy Swims is a compilation album, because most of its tracks are from two EPs. But those EPs came out in 2023 and 2025, and had the same title but with “(Part 1)” and “(Part 2)” appended, so it hardly seems fair to count it against him. ↩︎
  3. The Beatles (1967–1970), Bob Marley and the Wailers (Legend), Fleetwood Mac (Rumours), Queen (Greatest Hits) and Michael Jackson (Thriller again). Notice that three of those are compilation albums, a topic we’ll come on to. ↩︎
  4. I’ve always wondered why the extra one-third. But it means that each revolution takes exactly 1.8 seconds, which to be honest doesn’t really explain it. ↩︎

One response to “The charts of the charts”

Privacy and cookies

By leaving a comment you acknowledge that you have read and agreed to the privacy policy. If you tick the box marked “Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment”, a cookie will be saved in your browser so that this information can be saved; by ticking the box you consent to this necessary cookie.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.